Log In | Register

Key Idea: New species can arise when barriers to reproduction within a population lead to two populations that over time experience different environmental conditions.

Students are expected to know that:

  1. Speciation begins when barriers to reproduction within a population lead to two reproductively isolated populations whose alleles are no longer mixing.
  2. Reproductively isolated populations may independently gain or lose alleles through mutation, allele shuffling, and natural selection.
  3. Over time, reproductive isolation may lead to differences between populations and to new species.
  4. One way to define species is a group that includes individuals capable of reproducing with each other.
  5. Because individuals from two different species cannot reproduce with each other, their alleles cannot mix.
Percent of students answering correctly (click on the item ID number to view the item and additional data)
Item ID
Number
Knowledge Being Assessed Pre-Test Post-Test (Control) Post-Test (Treatment) Select This Item for My Item Bank

SP005003

For two populations of the same species to become two different species, the populations must be separated so that they cannot reproduce with each other, and they have to experience different environmental conditions.

59%

64%

69%

SP006002

When two populations of organisms interbreed, alleles from one will be found in the other (trout in Lakes Unknown, Mystery, and Forgotten).

57%

57%

65%

SP002002

If individuals from two populations of birds (Meadowlarks) cannot reproduce with each other, that is evidence that they are two different species.

51%

67%

77%

SP004002

If two populations stop reproducing with each other, any new alleles that arise through mutation in one of the populations will not be transferred to the other population.

50%

42%

54%

SP008002

The best evidence that two organisms (red monkeyflower plants and pink monkeyflower plants) do not reproduce with each other is the absence of allele mixing in their offspring.

45%

50%

55%

SP001001

If individuals from two populations of fish (cichlids) cannot reproduce with each other, that is evidence that they are two different species.

44%

66%

76%

SP009004

The best evidence that organisms from two populations (Cichlid fish) are from the same species is the presence of allele mixing in their offspring.

43%

45%

51%

CA018003

Cats and dogs became two different species when two groups in the ancestral species population became separated and could no longer breed with each other. Over time, the descendants of one group became cats and descendants of the other group became dogs.

39%

62%

67%

SP007004

Given three populations of fish, changes in the distribution of alleles in those populations occurs when the populations become separated and different gene mutations occur in the different populations.

29%

39%

53%

SP003005

Not being able to reproduce together provides the strongest evidence that two similar organisms are different species (the Annosum fungus in Europe and Asia).

29%

44%

59%

Frequency of selecting a misconception

Misconception
ID Number

Student Misconception

Pre-Test Post-Test (Control) Post-Test (Treatment)

ENM069

The only thing required for two populations to become different species is different environmental conditions. Reproductive isolation is not needed. (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.)

59%

64%

69%

ENM067

Genetic differences are sufficient evidence that two organisms are different species (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.).

42%

28%

18%

ENM060

Speciation occurs when two different species interbreed. Their offspring is a new species which has characteristics from both parent species. For example, students may believe that dogs and cats are different species because some members of an ancestral population bred with a dog-like species while others bred with a cat-like species (AAAS project 2061, n.d.).

33%

16%

15%

ENM066

The way to determine whether two organism are different species is to compare their ecological differences (for example, what the organisms eat or where the organisms live) (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.).

19%

11%

8%

ENM068

The only thing required for two groups of organisms to become different species is reproductive isolation. The groups do not need to experience different environments. (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.)

14%

13%

8%

ENM071

Phenotypic differences are sufficient evidence that two organisms are different species (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.).

12%

10%

5%

ENM070

Two populations of the same species cannot become two different species. (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.)

10%

18%

19%

Frequency of selecting a misconception was calculated by dividing the total number of times a misconception was chosen by the number of times it could have been chosen, averaged over the number of students answering the questions within this particular idea.

No NGSS statements are associated with this idea in the selected project.