Log In | Register

Key Idea: Energy can be transferred mechanically when an object exerts a force on another object even if the objects are not in contact.

Students should know that:

  1. When one object pushes or pulls on another object at a distance (such as gravitational, magnetic, and electric forces), energy is transferred mechanically from the one object to the other, and the speed (velocity) of both objects changes (assuming no other forces act on the objects).
  2. Because gravitational, magnetic, and electric forces do not require a physical medium (gas, liquid, or solid) to operate, energy can be transferred by these non-contact forces in the absence of such a physical medium.
  3. Energy is transferred as long as one object exerts a force on another object. The transfer of energy stops when the one object no longer exerts a force on the other object.
  4. When two forces act over the same distance and in the same direction, the stronger force transfers more energy than the weaker force.
  5. When a magnet is brought close to another magnet or magnetized object, the magnet pushes or pulls on the magnet/object even when they are not touching. This push or pull transfers energy to the magnet/object and causes the motion of the magnet/object to change. Examples of this include
    1. a magnet being brought close to a metal paper clip causing the paper clip to move toward the magnet and
    2. like poles of two magnets being brought close to each other causing the magnets to move away from each other.

Boundaries:

  1. Assessment items are limited to systems containing two objects that are moving or that can be moved. Examples of forces acting at a distance include magnets pushing or pulling on other magnets or magnetized objects, interactions between electrically charged objects, and the earth exerting a gravitational force on objects near it.
  2. Items do not ask students to calculate how much energy is transferred mechanically in a particular situation.
  3. Assessment items donot use the word “work” because students tend to confuse the lay definition of work and the scientific definition of work.
  4. For magnetic interactions, assessment items are limited to systems containing macroscopic magnets and macroscopic magnetized objects, and not individual particles in a magnetic field. In items involving a magnetic interaction, one magnet will be held in a stationary position so that the change in speed will be in the other magnet or magnetized object.
  5. The idea that a change in position or shape is necessary for energy to be transferred is not assessed at this level. This idea is introduced at the advanced level.
Frequency of selecting a misconception

Misconception
ID Number

Student Misconception

Grades
4–5

Grades
6–8

Grades
9–12

NGM005

Energy can be transformed into a force (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.).

N/A

37%

37%

RGM099

The amount of energy transferred by a magnet doesn't depend on distance.

22%

26%

25%

RGM082

Magnets transfer energy all the time (AAAS Project 2061, n.d.). Student say "whenever a magnet is close to a iron block it transfers energy" (zzzzfc/811/17) or "The magnetic field transfers energy to the metal at all times..."(zzzzfc/773/17).

23%

25%

24%

RGM069

As the distance between two charges increases, the potential energy decreases because the charges are further apart and have less effect on one another (Lindsey, 2014).

N/A

24%

24%

NGM064

Gravity supports the function of magnets (Bar, IJSE 1997).

N/A

21%

22%

RGM046

Only contact forces can transfer energy

20%

17%

17%

EGM048

Living things give inanimate objects energy by carrying or pushing them. For example, a person gives a bike energy by riding it or a bird give a stick energy by carrying it (Herrmann-Abell & DeBoer, 2010).

N/A

18%

15%

NGM010

Energy can be created (Kruger, 1990; Lovrude, 2004; Papadouris et al., 2008).

N/A

18%

16%

RGM064

Two forces acting over the same distance will transfer the same amount of energy even when the two forces are different strengths.

16%

16%

18%

RGM100

Magnets transfer forces, not energy.

14%

13%

13%

Frequency of selecting a misconception was calculated by dividing the total number of times a misconception was chosen by the number of times it could have been chosen, averaged over the number of students answering the questions within this particular idea.