Log In | Register

Item RG132002: When comparing three springs, the spring that is harder to stretch will have more elastic potential energy than the other springs if they are all stretched the same amount.

A student has three springs and would like to compare the elastic potential energy the springs have when stretched. He stretches all three springs 5 cm and lets go, which allows them to go back to their unstretched lengths. He makes several observations about each spring and records his observations in the table below:

Spring How difficult to stretch? Unstretched Length Weight
1 Easiest to stretch Shortest In between 2 and 3
2 Hardest to stretch In between 1 and 3 Lightest
3 In between 1 and 2 Longest Heaviest

Based on his findings, the student decides that Spring 3 has the most elastic potential energy. Is the student’s conclusion accurate?

  1. Yes, Spring 3 has the most elastic potential energy because the heavier a spring is the more elastic potential energy it has.
  2. Yes, Spring 3 has the most elastic potential energy because the longer a spring is the more elastic potential energy it has.
  3. No, Spring 1 has the most elastic potential energy because the easier a spring is to stretch, the more elastic potential energy it has.
  4. No, Spring 2 has the most elastic potential energy because the harder a spring is to stretch, the more elastic potential energy it has.
Distribution of responses
Answer Choice
Overall
Grades
Gender
Primary Language
 
n = 4716
4–5
n = 721
6–8
n = 1964
9–12
n = 2031
Male
n = 2117
Female
n = 2456
English
n = 4245
Other
n = 302
A. Yes, Spring 3 has the most elastic potential energy because the heavier a spring is the more elastic potential energy it has. 20%25% 21% 18% 21% 20% 20% 21%
B. Yes, Spring 3 has the most elastic potential energy because the longer a spring is the more elastic potential energy it has. 30%29% 29% 31% 31% 29% 30% 31%
C. No, Spring 1 has the most elastic potential energy because the easier a spring is to stretch, the more elastic potential energy it has. 25%26% 25% 24% 21% 28% 25% 23%
D. No, Spring 2 has the most elastic potential energy because the harder a spring is to stretch, the more elastic potential energy it has. 25%20% 24% 28% 27% 23% 25% 25%